AWAITING DATA
UNBOUGHT SCORE
Awaiting first-hand reads
Q
QuickBooks Payroll
Payroll built into QuickBooks — best for businesses already in the Intuit ecosystem.
HR
Pricing
Paid
Learning curve
Easy
Time to value
Days
BEST FOR1-1011-50
WORKS FOR
Businesses already using QuickBooks Online for accounting
KEY INSIGHT
If you already run QuickBooks, adding payroll takes minutes — no data re-entry.
DOESN'T WORK FOR
Businesses not using QuickBooks — integration is the main value prop
Related Tools
Square Payroll25.9% CONF
66/100
Simple payroll for hourly teams that already use Square POS.
Gusto99.7% CONF
63/100
Cloud-based payroll, benefits, and HR platform for small businesses.
OnPay9.5% CONF
60/100
Transparent flat-rate payroll with strong support for niche industries.
Trinet9.5% CONF
60/100
Professional Employer Organization (PEO) providing HR, payroll, benefits, and co…
FIRST-HAND READS
What people reported, in their own words. Every line links to where it was said.
“managed to screw up state filings such that I had 2 years of bad filings with the state where they were charging me late fees for things QP screwed up. Huge hassle, cost me days of time and a drive to the state capital to turn in paperwork in person. I swore off quickbooks payroll”
NEGATIVE · reliability · Hacker News · 2025-11-04
Have You Used This Tool?
Sign in to share your experience with this tool.
Sign in